By Ray W. Kelly
(Phillies beat writer 1964 through 1981)
Perhaps the greatest stumbling block is a man named Bill James, a renowned baseball historian and statistical guru. In 1985 he wrote a book entitled The Historical Baseball Abstract. It was hailed as the “holy book of baseball,” a classic.
In it, the newly-crowned “Sultan of Statistics” said this about Dick Allen:
“Dick Allen did more to keep his teams from winning than anyone else who ever played major league baseball.”
James, who never met Allen or even saw him play, went on to add that Allen was the second most controversial player in baseball history, behind Rogers Hornsby.
It was a damning assessment, one that instantly became the gospel truth to a lot of people, many of them baseball people, some of them voting sportswriters.
James has never provided an ounce of evidence as to what brought him to draw such dire conclusions concerning Dick Allen. Whenever attempts were made to discover the reason he embarked upon such slander, he simply vanished into the woodwork. Continue reading →